Hire With An Open Mind
February 28, 2011 1 Comment
Post Written by Valerie Freeman, CEO of Imprimis Staffing
I have been reading about and of course, as a staffing company owner, hearing from some recruiter friends that they prefer to hire the employed. Not everyone, of course, refuses to interview unemployed folks, but the biased attitudes surrounding the subject are similar to those surrounding the biased attitudes towards other groups such as older workers. Since we’ve been placing people for some 29 years, I can say with some authority that there is virtually no difference in the employed vs. unemployed talent pool. When you explore the reasons why people are unemployed, you can most likely figure out if the layoff or termination is valid and if equal consideration should be given to these candidates right along with those who happen to be employed. As in any large group of candidates (and the current economy made the unemployed much larger than normal), there are the talented, the mediocre and the just plain bad) just as in the group of candidates that are employed. How do you know if the employed candidate is looking because they are about to be terminated or their employer is dying to get rid of them – you don’t. How do you know if the employed candidate has the best skills that you can find – you don’t.
John Sullivan wrote an article on this subject for ERE entitled “Refusing Applications from the Unemployed: Best Practice or Madness”. In this article he states that there are more negative arguments associated with the practice of refusing to consider the unemployed than positive ones and that he has never recommended this practice. You can read his article and the comments here.
I would caution all recruiters and hiring managers to be as free from bias as possible when looking at candidates. I know for a fact that some of the best employees of companies came from the ranks of the unemployed; I know for a fact that some of the best employees of companies are over the age of 50; I know for a fact that some of the best employees of companies didn’t fit the mold for the perfect candidate for the job.







